Wow, I have been seriously sleeping on Ethan Brown, author of Queens Reigns Supreme: Fat Cat, 50 Cent, and the Rise of the Hip Hop Hustler and the upcoming Snitch: Informers, Cooperators, and the Corruption of Justice. What can I say? When I first heard about Queens Reign Supreme I didn't know anything about Mr. Brown and I assumed that any book on such a topic would include more fairy tales, as did From Pieces to Weight.
I'm also guessing that I was in one of my "not reading hip hop blogs" phases when Queens Reign Supreme came out and when Brown's blog launched cause what I've been reading today fits the mass of evidence on view better than anybody else I've read.
In particular, I was taken by the following breakdown:
Just as hip-hop has adopted a pathetic frat boy pose it has also provided myth-laden portrayals of what goes on in streets and in the criminal justice system. I’ve written this before but it bears repeating over and over again: the sentencing guidelines for drug related crimes established during the 1980s crushed any real “code of silence” on the streets (as did the rise of the crack trade which democratized the drug business and therefore put individual hustlers out on the streets who didn’t adhere to any specific code). Yes, witness intimidation still exists but there is no iron-clad code of silence out there. And by pledging allegiance to a code of “ethics” (as Cam put it) that does not exist, rappers look extraordinarily foolish. Chuck D famously said that hip-hop is the “CNN” of the black community but rap these days is more like Fox News.
I will say that his comments about M-1 partially miss the mark. Brown states that M-1 "didn’t make a single coherent argument" when he appeared on Fox News.
Actually, M-1's argument was quite coherent but totally in the wrong frame. M-1 entered an argument that was inspired by pop stars not talking to cops and discussed it as if everybody was talking about the interplay of revolutionary politics, race and poverty. Yes, it's connected and folks are trying to take it there, often in a rather superficial manner, but anyone mentioning Cop Watch in such a discussion is not in the same room with the rest of the folks on camera.
I don't know about now but, in the 90s, Copwatch was primarily an anarchist, radical leftist project that developed autonomous groups organizing citizens watches against police brutality at demonstrations and in heated community settings. It's an amazing tale and very important to democracy but that's just not the conversation M-1 dropped in on at Fox. He's doing more of a parallel universe type approach, though I doubt he recognizes that he's the one that set that up.
In any case, I'm glad I finally got on to Ethan Brown and I'm sure you'll be hearing more about him soon, both at Ski Mask Way and ProHipHop.
Thanks Rafi.
Recent Comments